Categorized | news

‘Under God’ at Issue Acton, MA Atheists take Fight to Court

By Jennifer C. Braceras, Boston Herald

Acton, Mass., doesn’t usually jump to mind when we think of hotbeds of “political correctness.” In fact, Acton probably wouldn’t make most people’s top 10 list.

Until today.

This morning, Superior Court Judge Jane Haggerty is scheduled to hear arguments in Doe vs. Acton-Boxborough Regional School District. The case, brought by an Acton family, asks the court to order Acton schools to remove the phrase “under God” from the Pledge of Allegiance.

The plaintiffs, who call themselves the “Does” to protect their identity, are atheists — albeit not particularly courageous ones, as they attempt to remain anonymous in their lack of belief.

Like the moonbats from Brookline, who sought to ban the recitation of the Pledge last September, and the members of the Arlington School Board who resisted reinstating the Pledge for fear of hurt feelings, the Does believe that the mere mention of God irreparably damages young hearts and minds.

Interestingly, the Does do not base their legal claim (as others before them have tried) on the First Amendment’s prohibition on state establishment of religion — what people colloquially call the “separation of church and state.”

Perhaps this is because they would be unlikely to convince a judge — even a Massachusetts judge — that the term “under God” in the Pledge establishes an official state religion.

The reference to God in the Pledge is meant to recognize the faith of our founders and their belief that all human beings are born with certain inalienable rights — rights, granted by God, and articulated in the Declaration of Independence, that can neither be given nor taken away by government. The phrase “one nation, under God” is, therefore, an expression of political philosophy and a nod to our history, not a religious oath.

Thus, instead of citing the “establishment clause,” the Does challenge the Pledge on the basis of the Massachusetts Constitution’s guarantee of “equal protection.” In other words, they claim that Acton schools discriminate against atheist children when they say the Pledge.

To be clear, the Does do not claim that Acton schools deny children the right to remain silent during the Pledge or that they punish kids who do not participate. The Does claim only that the schools discriminate against atheist children by participating in a Pledge that makes them feel “marginalized.”

Call it the doctrine of hurt feelings: where discrimination is defined by subjective experiences, not objective facts. And where courts are asked to find constitutional violations, in the absence of state coercion or force, any time a person feels excluded by community rituals, symbols or norms.

The Doe case is only the most recent example of the abuse of our legal system by plaintiffs who seek to cleanse society of anything that might offend.

Facebook Twitter Email Linkedin Delicious Stumbleupon

This post was written by:

- who has written 462 posts on The Report Card.


Contact the author

3 Responses to “‘Under God’ at Issue Acton, MA Atheists take Fight to Court”

  1. Bonnie says:

    May I encourage readers to read the book “The Pledge,” A History of the Pledge of Allegiance. I promise you: you will never again say the Pledge
    without realizing and appreciating its unique, controversial and fragile history from the gitgo, tying its collective recitation debut to the Columbus 400th in 1892 and the campaign to plant American flags outside every schoolhouse in America to all of the legal cases and amendments over the years. Authors are Jeffery Owen Jones (who died before pub.) and Peter Meyer who continued the research and writing. How interesting that the Acton legal case once again links MA to this most memorized and recited saying in all American history, if not the history of the world. If the plaintiffs from Acton, MA knew that the original Pledge was written by a Boston, ex-minister socialist-journalist, would it make any difference to them?

  2. Terry Sawyer says:

    Thanks for fіnally writing about > ‘Under God’ at Issue Acton, MA Atheists take Fight to Court | The Report Card
    < Loved it!

  3. Bob says:

    Taking God and prayer out of our schools wasn’t bad enough,now you want to take the line one nation under God out. You people are pathetic!! You in turn bring in various forms of new age and far eastern religions ie yoga (which is the worship of a hindu god shiva) and take in forms of Islam. You are setting yourself and your poor children up for some extremely troublesome times. I say to you wakeup and if at least spare your little ones the peril of Hell you’re bringing on yourself and this nation! Y’W'H,Y’SHUA, and the Holy Spirit will always be to God be the glory and the day of truth and judgement for all unbelievers is at hand. Turn from your wickedness while the day of salvation and grace is still available. God is not mocked whatever you sew you will reap. Turn back to God now and forsake your lying lowdown imoral ways while there is still time. Wake UP!!!!!!

Trackbacks/Pingbacks


Click the “LIKE” button below to follow us on Facebook

High School Students: Enter the Battle of Midway Essay Contest, Win $1000, national recognition!

Donate to The Report Card

Subscribe to Newsletters


Social links powered by Ecreative Internet Marketing